Talk:Collectio XCVIII capitulorum: Difference between revisions
Selected Canon Law Collections, ca. 500–1234
Latest comment: 17 December by Christof Rolker in topic Authorship
Clemens Radl (talk | contribs) →Authorship: new section |
→Authorship: Reply |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== Connection with CDP == | ==Connection with CDP== | ||
An earlier version of the description stated: | An earlier version of the description stated: | ||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
I believe the 2005 handbook p. {{FM|91}} refers to other canonistic material present in the mss. of the Coll. XCVIII capit. but also in Clm 6241 and Clm 6245 (thus, the so called "Freising collecton of canonical matierals", cf. Kéry, Collections p. {{Kéry|185}}). As I am not sure that the CDP really used the Coll. XCVIII capit., I have removed the sentence. [[User:Clemens Radl|Clemens Radl]] ([[User talk:Clemens Radl|talk]]) 12:39, 17 December 2025 (CET) | I believe the 2005 handbook p. {{FM|91}} refers to other canonistic material present in the mss. of the Coll. XCVIII capit. but also in Clm 6241 and Clm 6245 (thus, the so called "Freising collecton of canonical matierals", cf. Kéry, Collections p. {{Kéry|185}}). As I am not sure that the CDP really used the Coll. XCVIII capit., I have removed the sentence. [[User:Clemens Radl|Clemens Radl]] ([[User talk:Clemens Radl|talk]]) 12:39, 17 December 2025 (CET) | ||
== Authorship == | ==Authorship== | ||
As no part of the text was taken from Linda's handbook and there was no mention of the collection in the handbook and the article was originally created by [[User:Christof Rolker|Christof Rolker]], I suggest to change the first author from Linda to Christof. [[User:Clemens Radl|Clemens Radl]] ([[User talk:Clemens Radl|talk]]) 13:46, 17 December 2025 (CET) | As no part of the text was taken from Linda's handbook and there was no mention of the collection in the handbook and the article was originally created by [[User:Christof Rolker|Christof Rolker]], I suggest to change the first author from Linda to Christof. [[User:Clemens Radl|Clemens Radl]] ([[User talk:Clemens Radl|talk]]) 13:46, 17 December 2025 (CET) | ||
:I think Linda's name was used as default author, like Lotte's for mss articles. This made sense when we mainly imported from theie books but can now end [[User:Christof Rolker|Christof Rolker]] ([[User talk:Christof Rolker|talk]]) 14:02, 17 December 2025 (CET) | |||
Latest revision as of 14:02, 17 December 2025
Connection with CDP
An earlier version of the description stated:
in the 2005 handbook, it was mentioned in passing in the context of 12P which draws on it (though not by name)
I believe the 2005 handbook p. 91 refers to other canonistic material present in the mss. of the Coll. XCVIII capit. but also in Clm 6241 and Clm 6245 (thus, the so called "Freising collecton of canonical matierals", cf. Kéry, Collections p. 185). As I am not sure that the CDP really used the Coll. XCVIII capit., I have removed the sentence. Clemens Radl (talk) 12:39, 17 December 2025 (CET)
Authorship
As no part of the text was taken from Linda's handbook and there was no mention of the collection in the handbook and the article was originally created by Christof Rolker, I suggest to change the first author from Linda to Christof. Clemens Radl (talk) 13:46, 17 December 2025 (CET)
- I think Linda's name was used as default author, like Lotte's for mss articles. This made sense when we mainly imported from theie books but can now end Christof Rolker (talk) 14:02, 17 December 2025 (CET)
